Textual content measurement
Buyers ought to ask themselves why Volkswagen is value nothing when its stake in Porsche is backed out.
AFP by way of Getty Photos
European auto makers
Volkswagen
and
Porsche
each reported third quarter numbers Friday and making sense of the numbers is a problem. Generally the market doesn’t make sense.
VW (ticker: VOW3.Germany) reported $4.3 billion in third quarter working revenue. Wall Road was on the lookout for $4.5 billion. Shares are down 3.8% in abroad buying and selling.
The inventory dropping on an earnings miss isn’t shocking.
Volkswagen
didn’t change full 12 months monetary steering and nonetheless plans to make roughly 20 billion in working revenue in 2022.
Monetary steering hasn’t modified, however supply steering has. Again in July, Volkswagen believed whole deliveries in 2022 would rise 5% to 10% in contrast with the 2021 whole of 8.9 million models. Now the corporate expects 2022 deliveries to be the identical as 2021. Provide chain constraints are responsible.
Regardless of that headwind VW’s EV enterprise continued to increase within the quarter. Battery electrical automobiles amounted to 6.8% of whole VW deliveries. 12 months up to now, VW has delivered 366,400 EVs, up from 293,000 delivered in the identical interval of 2021. China accounted for 112,700 of these 2022 EV deliveries. VW’s Chinese language EV gross sales are up 139% to date in 2022 in contrast with the identical span of 2021.
As for
Porsche
,
in its first quarter as a publicly traded firm, it reported about $1.5 billion in working revenue. That’s somewhat higher than the Road was anticipating. Shares had been down in abroad buying and selling, however have rallied and at the moment are up about 0.5%.
The preliminary drop is a small a part of what’s obscure about Porsche and VW numbers. The far bigger conundrum stays valuation.
With at this time’s strikes. Volkswagen inventory, much less the share of Porsche it owns, is value nearly nothing–about $1 billion. Porsche has a market capitalization of roughly $91 billion. VW owns about 80% of that inventory, or nearly $73 billion. And Volkswagen’s whole market capitalization is about $74 billion.
(Adjusted for debt makes issues look worse, it makes VW as an entity value lower than zero.)
That worth is regardless of estimates that VW working revenue in 2022, excluding all of Porsche’s earnings, ought to come to $13 billion or $14 billion.
An organization buying and selling for 0.07 occasions 2022 working revenue ($1 billion divided by $13.5 billion) is difficult to reconcile. Porsche trades for roughly 15 occasions working revenue. Luxurious manufacturers, in fact, get greater valuations.
Ferrari
(RACE) trades for about 30 occasions estimated 2022 working revenue. However nonetheless, 0.07 occasions? What’s extra, VW has luxurious companies excluding Porsche. It owns Audi.
Third quarter numbers weren’t a catalyst for traders to re-evaluate the odd state of affairs. Possibly present valuations are a chance. They give the impression of being that manner. However it’s exhausting to argue with the market and win. Nonetheless, generally the market is fallacious.
S&P 500
and
Dow Jones Industrial Common
futures are down 0.5% and 0.1%, respectively.
Write to Al Root at allen.root@dowjones.com