Vodafone wants a radical new chief to result in actual change

Vodafone has lastly answered buyers’ calls, parting methods with chief government Nick Learn after 4 lacklustre years. What’s not but clear is whether or not the board has the heart to interchange him with somebody who can actually result in change.

It’s true that European telecoms has been a depressing investor expertise all spherical however Learn has finished little to ease the ache. Bettering Vodafone’s funding case would have required roughly three issues: simplifying the group’s advanced conglomerate construction, lowering its debt and bettering the way it was run. Learn has did not do sufficient on any of these counts.

Sure, there’s been the disposal of Vodafone’s Hungarian unit this 12 months and, extra materially, a deal to place what stays of its masts enterprise, Vantage Towers, right into a three way partnership with personal fairness and infrastructure buyers after a partial float final 12 months. And its Egyptian property have been shuffled into an affiliate, Vodacom, a 12 months in the past.

However this isn’t simplification on something like the size Vodafone wants. Learn has did not do offers the place it counts, lacking out on the possibility to do one thing with MasMovil in Spain, permitting Virgin Media and O2 to consolidate within the UK and failing to get out of the Towers enterprise in full final 12 months earlier than rising rates of interest began eroding the worth of its stake.

Even talks to mix with CK Hutchison’s Three within the UK might come too late, as price of dwelling considerations make it tougher for regulators to sign-off on a deal the primary attraction of which might be to permit operators to enhance their returns, in all probability by way of larger costs. Within the meantime, Vodafone’s efficiency in its most necessary market, Germany, has faltered.

What Vodafone wants is radical reform. Cevian’s substantial exit from the shareholder register in June, lower than a 12 months after its curiosity was first disclosed, suggests the activist investor was sceptical in regards to the probabilities of it occurring any time quickly. In idea, Learn’s departure might be an indication the board has determined to buck up its act. However there are causes to fret that Monday’s announcement will imply simply extra of the identical.

The board has dedicated to a correct seek for a chief, however within the meantime has put in chief monetary officer Margherita Della Valle as interim chief government. That transfer in all probability is smart: within the tight-knit world of telecoms it will be exhausting to conduct a severe succession competitors and preserve it quiet. However Vodafone has additionally bumped up Della Valle’s pay and incentives package deal to match Learn’s, a transfer that makes her look worryingly like a shoo-in for the everlasting put up.

Add to that the truth that in its complete historical past, Vodafone has did not appoint anybody to both of the highest two jobs with out them having substantial inner expertise, as Berenberg analyst Carl Murdock-Smith factors out.

A candidate with substantial inner expertise is just not what Vodafone wants, as advanced a conglomerate because it is perhaps. It wants somebody keen to unsentimentally sacrifice its sacred cows, in any other case buyers face years of slog as administration makes an attempt to eke out enhancements whereas untangling an unwieldy mess. Della Valle, who has been with Vodafone for even longer than Learn’s 21 years, is just not the “change” candidate shareholders search.

There’s hope that current board appointments might function a catalyst for a broader overhaul. It was once that the board was lengthy on Metropolis grandees, brief on telecoms experience. There are nonetheless a number of the former. For the reason that begin of the 12 months, although, Vodafone has added 5 new non-executives, 4 of them with substantial know-how and telecoms government expertise.

It’s not apparent whether or not the board is daring sufficient to select the type of exterior candidate who might shrink Vodafone again to a lovely core, nevertheless. Because the current chief government of Heineken, Jean-François van Boxmeer’s credentials as a chair have been unclear when he took up the Vodafone job two years in the past. Since then he has allowed Learn and Della Valle an excessive amount of time and an excessive amount of latitude.

The corporate’s assurance that Della Valle’s short-term promotion will “speed up the execution of the corporate’s technique” is little consolation when it looks as if a complete new technique is required to begin with.

cat.rutterpooley@ft.com
@catrutterpooley