International cities are fragile by nature. Listed below are some on their manner down

Cádiz is a Spanish backwater remoted in Europe’s backside left nook. However strolling the 18th-century streets dripping with gold, you realise: this was as soon as a worldwide metropolis. Then, in 1778, it misplaced its near-monopoly on commerce with the Americas. To cite Hitchcock’s Psycho: “They moved away the freeway.” Cádiz froze in time.

Related shocks did for Babylon and Alexandria. Now a few of at present’s international cities are below risk. The wrongest prediction of the pandemic was that cities would die. However on this interval of historic acceleration, varied forces — authoritarianism, distant work and, quickly, local weather change — are upending the hierarchy of worldwide cities. Hong Kong, San Francisco, Beijing and Moscow are shedding, whereas at present’s winners Dubai and Miami are in danger.

The consultancy Kearney defines “international cities” as locations that “appeal to and retain international capital, folks, and concepts”. These locations are fragile by nature. Ethnic conflicts stripped Constantinople and Beirut of their international standing. Fairly not too long ago, Islamist terrorism appeared to threaten Paris and London. 

However the greater menace turned out to be nationalist authoritarianism. China’s Communist celebration distrusts international cities. It’s crushing Hong Kong, and individuals are fleeing. When a marquee 800-flat mission opened final month, zero residences offered. Hong Kong, fifth on Kearney’s global-city rating in 2019, is regressing into what some name “simply one other Chinese language metropolis”.

Beijing and Shanghai, amongst Kearney’s high 10 final 12 months, have additionally misplaced entry to the world, supposedly due to quarantine restrictions. Final month, China averaged about 100 worldwide flights a day, down 96 per cent since 2020, says Variflight. After this week’s celebration congress, these cities might turn out to be international once more, or maybe these days are over.

Then there’s Moscow, ranked third-most affluent metropolis by the UN in February, simply earlier than Russia invaded Ukraine. All the time an imperial capital and, across the 12 months 2010, greater than that, Moscow supplied what the FT’s Max Seddon calls “hipster totalitarianism”: skateboards and oligarchs. Its goodbye to the world is scattering the hipsters.

The brand new stylish authoritarian-run international metropolis is Dubai, whose inhabitants has grown 165-fold since 1950. It’s at the moment the final place the place Arabs, Russians and westerners nonetheless combine. I wouldn’t wager on it long run.

The west’s fastest-shrivelling international metropolis is San Francisco, which has managed the uncommon feat of turning into concurrently seedy and unaffordable. Twenty years in the past, a pal in tech instructed me he might discover no motive to not transfer there. As we speak he most likely might. A plutocracy filled with homeless folks, it’s as soon as once more the place the place I met a pleasant mugger in 1990. Even San Francisco’s principal newspaper editorialised final month: “This metropolis is damaged.”

When distant working arrived, younger San Franciscans grabbed the possibility to flee. Inhabitants, rents and international funding have slumped. San Francisco dangers turning into the subsequent Detroit: a single-industry city with out the {industry}. Put up-Large Tech, it is perhaps extra habitable, as a result of international and habitable are various things.

Round 2010, Moscow supplied ‘hipster totalitarianism’: skateboards and oligarchs

In the meantime, our period’s 4 nice international cities — New York, London, Paris and Tokyo — thrive. Distant work has improved liveability by decreasing commutes. London’s success typically irks provincial England, which tried a revenge by means of Brexit. That failed, and London’s financial system has pulled even additional away.

I’m biased, however I believe Paris, the place I stay, has probably the most scope to develop. Overcentralised France is about to centralise additional. Sixty-eight metro stations are being dug in Paris’s suburbs. In contrast to New York and London, Paris sits on an enormous plain with out a greenbelt, so it might develop without end, even triple in dimension, if Tokyo’s 37mn inhabitants is the benchmark. Room to develop additionally favours Berlin, Europe’s fastest-rising international metropolis, and Madrid, the place you may drive from downtown to the nation in quarter-hour.

The approaching risk to international cities is local weather change. As soon as Miami was Havana’s boring little anglophone sister, a backwater dreaming of low-cost air-conditioning and jet journey. As we speak, bilingual Miami tops the US’s rankings for international direct funding per capita. The horrifying factor about Hurricane Ian, which devastated a lot of Florida whereas sparing Miami, is that it was anticipated. Town can be threatened by rising oceans. Sitting on porous limestone, it couldn’t hold out the waters even when it tried. As residence insurance coverage turns into unaffordable, getting a 25-year mortgage there’ll go from act of religion to behave of madness. Miami might fade like Hong Kong. New international cities will exchange it.

Observe Simon on Twitter @KuperSimon and e-mail him at simon.kuper@ft.com

Observe @FTMag on Twitter to seek out out about our newest tales first