Elon Musk’s Reckless Plan to Make Intercourse Pay on Twitter

In the meantime, I’ve scrolled previous exceedingly graphic grownup content material on Twitter, which doesn’t prohibit depictions of “bodily fluids” so long as customers flag it as delicate media. Whereas Twitter does prohibit “violent sexual conduct,” the coverage appears solely to use to rape and sexual assault versus consensual violence, as in BDSM.

Twitter doesn’t limit grownup content material as a result of it doesn’t have pointers for grownup content material. In any respect. On the time of writing this text, there aren’t any policies limiting adult content on Twitter so long as it’s consensually produced, appropriately flagged as delicate, and never included in additional publicly seen areas like profile photos or header photographs. (I don’t embody CSEM as “grownup content material” as a result of it, by definition, doesn’t function adults.)

Traditionally, whereas Twitter was by no means as hostile to intercourse staff as, say, Meta, it maintains what one Twitter worker instructed me is a “Don’t Ask, Don’t Inform” coverage in the direction of us. And regardless of its lack of content material coverage, Twitter does algorithmically suppress grownup content material, whether or not deliberately or not.

Realistically, not even Twitter is aware of how its algorithms are utilized, as is the case with most machine-learning algorithms utilized by social media and engines like google. Machine-learning algorithms refine themselves based mostly on person exercise that, with out interference, codifies the biases of these customers. This leads to what’s termed algorithmic bias that, on this case, even if unintentional, impacts intercourse staff most severely. Already, intercourse staff and activists usually tend to be algorithmically flagged by Twitter for shadowbanning, a follow wherein sure customers or content material is artificially suppressed. Moreover, and just like Instagram’s algorithms that flag nudity by flesh-toned pixels, Twitter algorithmically identifies grownup content material not already marked as “delicate” and restricts it.

In opposition to this backdrop, Musk’s plan to monetize grownup content material theoretically is smart from each a enterprise and a social standpoint. From a enterprise standpoint, it would deliver in additional income for Twitter. From a social standpoint, it may forestall algorithmic censorship of intercourse staff and theoretically destigmatize intercourse work. Fears that ACM would someway remodel Twitter into “a porn website” or, worse, “a baby porn website” are unfounded. If something, monetizing grownup content material appropriately may drastically cut back the quantity of CSEM on Twitter by placing in additional safeguards to detect it earlier than it’s posted.

In follow, nevertheless, Musk would both should decide to extra content material moderation to make sure that CSEM just isn’t on the location—which is in rigidity along with his championing of “free speech”—or double down on the significance of expression with minimal moderation, thus opening the floodgates for grotesque content material in any other case stored within the shadows of the darkish net and personal Fb teams.

If Twitter rolls out ACM, it would possible face a alternative: require all Twitter customers to offer age verification so as to forestall posting of or entry to CSEM, or ban non-monetized grownup content material totally so as to generate profits from its subscription service. Both manner, algorithmic surveillance of all visible media will essentially intensify.